LA Times, New Scientist, etc: Actual soft tissue from a T. rex? Looks more like a mould of mold, bacterial slime, and other muck
Thursday, July 31st, 2008
Fossilization occurs when minerals from a dead animal’s rocky tomb displace and replace its original organic molecules – preserving its form but not its biochemistry. Hopes had been high that discovery three years ago of preserved masses of what looked like soft tissue of a Tyrannosaurus rex comprised some of the original stuff. Not so, a new report suggests. Rather, in PloS One this week, researchers from the University of Washington say that microbes sometimes do what inorganic minerals do – infiltrate dead things and preserve the form of soft tissue – or at least leave residue that look an awful lot like T. rex meat, blood vessels, and such might look.
Darn. Another blow to dreams of reversing exinctions that novelist and fabulist Michael Crichton’s Jurassic Park spawned. Next thing you know, the notion that global warming is a lefty plot by Earth First and its conniving ilk will turn out to result from a biofilm in Crichton’s lofty cranium and not from sensible human thought.
Stories:
New Scientist Jeff Hecht includes in his report that at least one scientist – she reported the T. rex tissue’s possible provenance as the real thing – is not buying it ; Scientific American Adam Hadhazy reports that bacterial sludge “faked out researchers” looking at the T. rex fossil – and, like Hecht, reports that the original study’s main author wants to know if this is a biofilm, why do its proteins cluster with those of chickens – and all birds, really – the only living remnants of the dino clade? ; Reuters ; USA Today Dan Vergano has it nicely exept for one thing – or perhaps an editor made his text suggest a kinship between mammoths and birds? Vergano nonetheless also gets a sturdy ripost from the dino and mammoth protein team ; Nat’l Geographic News John Roach ditto seems to have received the same e-mail as the other reporters did from the original report’s author ;
Grist for the Mill: Univ of Washington Press Release ;
-CP