Lots of Ink: When it came to spotting horses, Cro-magnon artists were drawing on experience
Tuesday, November 8th, 2011
Archeology is interesting in most cases, but it gets sublime – maybe because it’s so easy to identify with and so impressive to look at – when it comes to petroglyphs, petroliths, and other drawings on a wall. I don’t look at flint arrowheads or Assyrian pottery and imagine making such things. But a picture, sure. As the recent ScienceWriters2011 meeting closed in Flagstaff, the most memorable moment of the field trip was to see the figures that some of the original residents left limned into the desert varnish on the bottom of a Glen Canyon cliff (check it out here). So it’s no wonder that a little spot of news has hit paydirt in news media. In the Proceeding of the National Academy of Sciences, scientists from Germany, the UK, and elsewhere report that new DNA analysis from the bones of ancient horses reveals – contrary to an earlier analysis – the gene patterns asssociated with spotted horses today were in some of their ancestors many thousands of years ago. A hypothesis that pastoral breeding created the spots seems dead – or at most it modified a pattern already in the wild.
Lots of outlets let this one out of the corral:
- ScienceNOW – Michael Balter: Cave Paintings Showed True Colors of Stone Age Horses ; Emphasizes that whle the oldtimers in Europe did paint spotted horses, they didn’t do it often.
- Guardian (UK, blog) Jonathan Jones: What DNA can’t tell us about the spotty horses ; I dunno what this writer’s problem is – the story seems to tell us that he was swept away first time and every time he’s seen some of the magnificent old works of art, and now he appears to be somehow offended that maybe this research robs the art of its magic. Or is it just me? CP Snow’s “two cultures” analysis may apply, and maybe this writer is in the science-phobic camp. It’s like he’s saying don’t try to explain it, for just to feel it is better. Reminds me of Yoda.
- NYTimes – Hillary Rosner: Spotted Horses in Cave Art Wern’t Just a Figment, DNA Shows ;
- AP – Alicia Chang: Cave painters were realists, DNA study finds ;
- BBC – Jennifer Carpenter : Ancient horses’ spotted history reflected in cave art ;
- LA Times – Eryn Brown: Ice age horse painters really did see sots, scientists say ;
- AFP : Cave Painters of ancient horses were realists: study ; Clearly, it’s convergent evolution. No, not the horses. This hed and the one at AP.
- Cosmos (Australia, filed from Cambridge, UK) Taylor Burns: Leopard print horse DNA sheds light on cave painting ;
- … Lots more..
Grist for the Mill: U. of York Press Release ;
- Charlie Petit